Infinite Options alternative: LemonPick vs Infinite Options
Looking for a Infinite Options alternative? This page compares LemonPick Product Options with Infinite Options by ShopPad (by ShopPad Inc.) using only what each app's Shopify App Store listing says. Both let you add custom options to Shopify products. They differ in price, feature depth and how they check your checkout totals.
Competitor details are taken from the public Infinite Options App Store listing as it appeared on October 24, 2026. Prices, plans and features change, so check the listing for the latest. "Not listed on its App Store page" means we didn't find it on that page. It doesn't mean the app can't do it.
LemonPick vs Infinite Options at a glance
| LemonPick | Infinite Options | |
|---|---|---|
| App Store rating | New app, no reviews yet | 4.7 (2,622 reviews) |
| Built for Shopify badge | No (new app) | Yes |
| Free plan | Yes: unlimited products and options, dropdowns, swatches, checkboxes, text fields, conditional logic, version history, Checkout Guard on demand. Options on Free can't carry a price. | No |
| Lowest plan that lists priced add-ons | Starter, $9.99/month ($99.90/year) | Essential, $12.99/month ("Addon products & price changes") |
| Plans and monthly prices | Free; Starter $9.99/mo; Growth $19.99/mo; Pro $29.99/mo (annual: $99.90, $199.90, $299.90) | One plan: The Essential Plan, $12.99/month |
| Free trial | 14 days on paid plans | 14 days |
| Option types | 5: dropdown, swatch buttons, checkbox, text field, file upload | Listed: text boxes, dropdowns, checkboxes, swatches (image and color), number, button, menu, date, file |
| Conditional logic | Yes, all plans | Yes |
| File upload | Starter and up (1 file per option, 10 MB) | Yes ("Advanced inputs: date, file, checkbox") |
| Live preview / personalizer | No | Not listed on its App Store page |
| Edit options in cart | No | Not listed on its App Store page |
| Languages | English | English |
| How add-on prices are applied | Shopify Functions (Cart Transform); the add-on fee stays on the product's cart line | Not listed on its App Store page |
| Automated test carts for add-on totals | Yes: Checkout Guard runs test carts and compares expected and actual add-on totals (on demand on Free; daily on Starter and Growth; hourly on Pro) | Not listed on its App Store page |
| Option version history / restore | Yes: every save is kept; one-click restore on Growth and Pro | Not listed on its App Store page |
Where Infinite Options may be the better fit
- A long track record: 2,622 reviews and a Built for Shopify badge.
- Product bundles with options, which LemonPick does not offer.
- More input types, including number and date fields.
- Listed integrations with GemPages, Klaviyo, MESA, Order Printer, Recharge and Uploadery.
Where LemonPick may be the better fit
- You want a free plan to set options up before paying. Infinite Options lists one paid plan.
- Priced add-ons start at $9.99/month on LemonPick Starter, compared with $12.99/month listed for Infinite Options.
- You want scheduled test carts that check add-on totals (Checkout Guard), plus version history with restore.
What makes LemonPick different: Checkout Guard
Add-on prices only matter if they're charged. Theme changes, discount codes and other apps can all affect the cart. LemonPick's Checkout Guard builds test carts for your products with add-ons selected and compares the expected and actual totals, including with a discount code you choose. It flags any add-on total that doesn't match, so you hear about it before a customer does. Every option change is also saved as a version you can review, and on Growth and Pro you can restore one in a click.
Switching from Infinite Options
- Install LemonPick and leave Infinite Options running while you set up.
- Open a product in LemonPick and recreate its options in the visual editor: dropdowns, swatches, checkboxes, text fields and file uploads, each with an optional price.
- Add the LemonPick "Product options" block to your product template in the theme editor, and remove the old app's block or embed.
- Run Checkout Guard to confirm your add-on totals, then uninstall the old app.
See also: how to charge extra for product options and all comparisons.
Install LemonPick from the Shopify App Store
Free plan available. Paid plans include a 14-day free trial.